| Saturday, 02/04/1960 | Sicilia - Corio | 2:5 | ||||||
| Saturday, 09/04/1960 | Coburg United - Sicilia | 2:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 16/04/1960 | Sicilia - South Melbourne Hellas | 0:0 | Forfeit 0:X | |||||
| Monday, 18/04/1960 | Croatia - Sicilia | 2:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 23/04/1960 | Sicilia - University of Melbourne | 4:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 30/04/1960 | Sicilia - Fiorentina | 0:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 07/05/1960 | Maccabi - Sicilia | 4:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 14/05/1960 | Sicilia - Sunshine City | 1:3 | ||||||
| Saturday, 21/05/1960 | Moonee Ponds - Sicilia | 3:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 04/06/1960 | Corio - Sicilia | 6:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 25/06/1960 | Sicilia - Coburg United | 1:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 02/07/1960 | South Melbourne Hellas - Sicilia | 6:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 16/07/1960 | Sicilia - Croatia | 0:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 23/07/1960 | University of Melbourne - Sicilia | 0:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 06/08/1960 | Fiorentina - Sicilia | 0:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 13/08/1960 | Sicilia - Maccabi | 2:4 | ||||||
| Saturday, 27/08/1960 | Sicilia - Moonee Ponds | 0:3 | ||||||
| Sunshine City - Sicilia | 0:0 | Forfeit X:0 |