| Saturday, 22/03/1986 | Karingal United - West Brunswick | 2:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 29/03/1986 | East Brunswick - Karingal United | 0:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 05/04/1986 | Karingal United - Heidelberg-Bundoora | 1:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 12/04/1986 | Keysborough - Karingal United | 3:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 19/04/1986 | Karingal United - Lalor United | 0:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 26/04/1986 | Boronia - Karingal United | 3:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 03/05/1986 | Karingal United - Langwarrin | 0:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 10/05/1986 | Holland Park - Karingal United | 2:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 17/05/1986 | Karingal United - Ballarat | 3:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 24/05/1986 | Clarinda - Karingal United | 2:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 07/06/1986 | Brighton - Karingal United | 0:5 | ||||||
| Saturday, 14/06/1986 | Karingal United - Hawthorn Citizens | 2:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 21/06/1986 | West Brunswick - Karingal United | 2:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 28/06/1986 | Karingal United - East Brunswick | 1:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 05/07/1986 | Heidelberg-Bundoora - Karingal United | 3:3 | ||||||
| Saturday, 12/07/1986 | Karingal United - Keysborough | 2:2 | ||||||
| Saturday, 19/07/1986 | Lalor United - Karingal United | 2:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 26/07/1986 | Karingal United - Boronia | 1:3 | ||||||
| Saturday, 02/08/1986 | Langwarrin - Karingal United | 4:3 | ||||||
| Saturday, 09/08/1986 | Karingal United - Holland Park | 1:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 16/08/1986 | Ballarat - Karingal United | 0:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 23/08/1986 | Karingal United - Clarinda | 0:0 | ||||||
| Saturday, 06/09/1986 | Karingal United - Brighton | 1:1 | ||||||
| Saturday, 13/09/1986 | Hawthorn Citizens - Karingal United | 4:1 |